Feeling frustrated by your outdated, drafty windows and considering a fresh start? You’re not alone! We’ve all been there, facing the dilemma of going for a full frame replacement or just an insert window replacement. If you want to know the difference between them, you’re exactly where you need to be!
In this guide, we’ll break down the ins and outs of these two popular window replacement options: full frame vs insert window replacement. We’ll help you navigate the maze of costs, installation processes, and potential benefits. So, grab a cup of coffee and a notebook to write down the pros and cons of both types of window replacements!
Key Takeaways
- Full frame window replacement means that the entire window unit is removed, including the frame, the trim, the jambs, and the windowsill. Then, a new window unit is installed within the rough opening. This option provides improved energy efficiency and insulation, design flexibility, and a longer window lifespan.
- Insert window replacement implies installing a new window within the existing frame. Therefore, only the old sash and hardware are removed. It is less expensive than full frame window replacement and an excellent method to improve energy efficiency if your current frames are in good shape.
- Full frame replacement can cost twice as much as insert window replacement. The choice between the two depends on the condition of your existing frames. If they’re in good shape and expected to perform well for many years to come, insert window replacement is definitely an option.
Full Frame vs Insert Window Replacement: What’s the Difference?
When it comes to replacing windows, you have two main options on the table: full frame and insert window replacements. Full frame window replacement means removing the entire window – the glass, the sash, the hardware, the frame, the trim, the jambs, the head, and the windowsill. You’re left with the rough window opening for a complete makeover. Then, you’re installing a brand new window.
Now, insert window replacement, also called pocket window replacement, is much quicker and simpler. You keep the existing frame and replace just the sash, the glass, and the hardware. If your frames are in decent shape, insert window replacement is definitely worth considering.
So, how do you choose? In a nutshell, it depends on whether your current frames are holding up okay, if you want to change the style and size of your windows, the purpose of the replacement, and your budget. We’ll discuss everything in detail below, so keep reading! Let’s start with a complete guide on full frame window replacement, and then we’ll move to the insert window replacement.
Full Frame Window Replacement
As mentioned above, full frame window replacement involves stripping everything away, including the window frame and trim. By doing this, you get a chance to inspect the area thoroughly for any hidden issues, like water damage or structural problems, that might not be visible when the windows are in place.
You should consider installing a full frame replacement window if:
- Your window frames are severely damaged – think of rotting wood and warped vinyl frames. Replacing the glazing is pointless because the frames won’t last too long, and you’ll have to replace the entire unit eventually.
- You’re planning a major renovation project – in this case, it’s best to go for full window replacement, as you may also have to change the frame and the trim to match your new home design.
- You want to change the size and style of your windows.
- You want to improve energy efficiency – this can also be achieved through insert window replacement as well, but if you want to go the extra mile in terms of insulation, it’s best to replace the frame as well, as it plays an important role in energy efficiency.
Advantages of Full Frame Window Replacement
One of the primary advantages of full frame window replacement is having a precise fit between the window sash and frame. This can significantly improve energy efficiency because there will be less heat transfer and no risk of drafts – at least in the beginning.
Secondly, removing the entire existing windows allows you to check for structural damage around your windows. If there’s water damage, for example, you’ll have the possibility to repair it before installing the new windows. This way, you make sure that you won’t have to deal with any repairs in the near future.
Thirdly, your windows will last much longer if the frame is new as well. Let’s say your current windows are 15 years old. The window frame is in good shape, so you decide to keep it and replace only the sash. In 10 years (or even sooner if you live in regions with harsh weather conditions), the frame will start degrading, while the sash and the glass will still be in good shape. Then, you’ll have to replace everything, even if the sash is still performing well. In other words, choosing an insert window replacement in this case will cost less initially, but in the long run, the expenses will be the same as or even higher than the costs of a full frame replacement.
Last but not least – design flexibility. If you plan to redecorate your house, it will be much easier to do so if you’re replacing the windows as well. There are countless design options nowadays, especially when it comes to window trim. A cohesive interior and exterior design can make your house feel more cozy, as well as improve its curb appeal and, therefore, also increase property value.
Disadvantages of Full Frame Window Replacement
The biggest disadvantage of full frame replacement windows is that they cost much more than insert window replacements – sometimes twice as much. There are more materials involved and the installation process is generally more complex. You may have to pay between $300 and $5,000+ per new window, depending on its style and size. Now, this may not be an issue if you’re replacing one window. If you’re replacing five, eight, or ten windows, it can become quite an investment.
Then, replacing the entire window takes more time. You may have to wait longer for the windows to be manufactured and delivered, and you may also have to wait longer to schedule the installation, especially during peak season.
Another potential downside is that you may have to replace the window trim as well, even if you haven’t planned to. This adds to the final price and complexity of the project.
Insert Window Replacement
Insert window replacement, often called pocket window replacement, is all about inserting (as its name implies) a new window into the existing window frame. In other words, you’re replacing only the sash, the glass, and the hardware. This method is, therefore, quicker and less invasive. Plus, it also keeps your interior and exterior trim intact, so you won’t have to worry about additional costs in this regard.
You should consider insert window replacement if:
- Your frames are in good condition.
- The manufacturer can accommodate the size and the style of the windows for insert window replacement.
- If you want to upgrade from single- to double-glazing or triple-glazing.
- If you live in an older home and you want to preserve the frames – as long as they are still performing well.
- If you’re looking for a quick, budget-friendly window replacement.
Advantages of Insert Window Replacement
One of the key advantages of insert window replacement is its cost-effectiveness. Since this method implies less labor and fewer materials, it usually costs much less than full frame replacements – usually 20%-30% less, but sometimes can even be half the price of new windows. Plus, you get to keep the original trim and frame, which is important if you don’t want to alter the design of your house. The installation process is quick as well – it usually takes 30 minutes per window.
Another major advantage of insert window replacement is the fact that you can quickly improve energy efficiency at a low cost. Let’s say you’ve just moved into a new house, the windows are in excellent shape, but you want them to be more energy-efficient. All you have to do is replace the glazing area – there’s no need to replace the frame. Not to mention that you can have your new window ready to be delivered and installed much faster.
Last but not least, installing insert window replacement isn’t as riskier in terms of damages caused to the surrounding structure because the installation process is less invasive.
If you’re a skilled handyman, you may even be able to perform an insert window replacement yourself!
Disadvantages of Insert Window Replacement
The most significant disadvantage of insert window replacement is the risk of poor insulation. You can indeed install more efficient Insulating Glass Units through insert window replacement, but there may still be cracks and gaps between the sash and the frame that let air and water in. To avoid this, the frame should be in perfect condition, the sash should be installed snugly, and the installers should apply insulation and caulking carefully.
And here’s the second drawback – it’s always best to use the same window company that has installed your current windows, as they know what windows you have and the materials used. They’ve already worked in your house, and the process will likely go faster and easier than with a new window company.
Installation Process Overview
Installing a new window unit is more complex and time-consuming than just inserting the sashes into an existing window frame. To help you understand what each implies, we’ve outlined the installation process for both window replacements.
Full frame installation implies:
- Removing the old window: the trim, sash, the hardware, the screens, and the frame. The steps are different based on the window type.
- Removing the windowsill, the jambs, and the head.
- Inspecting the rough opening to ensure there’s no damage and repairing it if needed.
- Changing the shape and size of the rough opening if needed.
- Installing the replacement window.
- Applying insulation to fill any gaps between the frame and the wall.
- Applying caulking and weatherstripping to fill any gaps between the window frame and the siding or drywall.
- Installing window trim on the interior and exterior if needed, as well as other window parts.
Insert window installation implies:
- Removing the old sashes, which will be replaced, leaving the frame intact.
- Cleaning the frame thoroughly to remove any dirt.
- Inspecting the window frame for damage.
- Adding insulation around the window frame and repairing anything that needs to be repaired.
- Inserting the new window within the existing frame and adjusting until it is aligned completely.
- Applying insulation between the new window and the existing window frame.
- Applying caulking if needed to fill any gaps.
Professional vs DIY Window Replacement
When it comes to windows, it’s always better to hire professionals, unless you have the experience and skills required for such a project. Given the considerable investment in either full-frame or insert window replacements, the potential savings from a DIY installation usually aren’t worth it.
Improper installation can cause window damage, water and air leaks, and compromised energy efficiency. In fact, the costs of correcting mistakes from a DIY installation can far surpass the budget required for hiring professional installers.
Experts can give you quality assurance and warranties, so you can relax knowing your windows will hold up and keep the heat in! They are already well-versed with all kinds of issues that may appear during installation and know how to solve them.
Insert Window Replacement vs Window Inserts
We have one last thing to discuss before wrapping everything up – the difference between insert window replacement and window inserts. They may sound similar, but they’re actually different things.
The term window inserts is usually used when referring to a type of storm window that is added to the interior window side. You can easily install a windowan window insert yourself by pressing it into place. It should fit within the window frame. There’s no need to remove the sash or any other window part. Window inserts can be easily removed if needed.
Looking For Replacement Windows? Get Magic Ones!
Our windows are truly magic – you’ll confirm this yourself! They’re so durable, energy-efficient, and easy to use that it really feels like they’ve got some magic within their hardware and window frame! But the truth is – it’s all about our skilled engineers and technicians!
Magic offers both full frame and insert window replacement, so if you’re not sure where to start, you can book a free consultation with us. One of our experts will assess the condition of your existing windows and provide you with a solution that’s fully tailored to your needs.
You’re one step closer to a warmer house in winter and a cooler house in summer! And, of course, you won’t need that ladder anymore to clean your windows, thanks to our revolutionary opening mechanisms!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between full frame and insert window replacement?
The main difference between full frame and insert window replacement is that the former implies removing the entire window, including the frame, the trim, and the windowsill, while insert replacement implies installing a new window within the existing frame, replacing only the sash and hardware.
Is full frame replacement worth it?
Full frame window replacement is worth it when your existing frames are damaged or if you want to change the size or style of your windows.
How much do full frame replacement windows cost?
Full frame replacement windows can cost between $300 and $5,000+, depending on window quality, size, and style. Insert window replacements are generally less expensive than full frame replacements, as they involve less labor and fewer materials.
Can insert window replacements improve energy efficiency?
Insert window replacements can indeed enhance energy efficiency, particularly when existing frames are well-maintained and ensure a snug fit for the new sashes.